CBS Justice Reporter Scott MacFarlane Leaves Network After Four Years

On March 9, 2026, CBS News justice correspondent Scott MacFarlane sent a note to colleagues that would have been unremarkable at most moments in American journalism. "My work will soon no longer appear on CBS News," he wrote. "This is my decision, and I appreciate the bosses at CBS for understanding it" [1]. He said he looked "forward to some independence and finding new spaces to share my work in line with my personal goals" [2].

But this was not a routine career move. MacFarlane's exit is the latest — and among the most symbolically significant — departures from a network that has, in the span of six months, undergone a transformation so sweeping that some of its own journalists have described the environment as "Propaganda-palooza" [3]. His departure is a story not just about one correspondent, but about what happens when corporate ownership, political pressure, and editorial independence collide inside one of American broadcasting's most storied institutions.

The Reporter Who Wouldn't Look Away

Scott MacFarlane spent more than two decades as a reporter in the Washington, D.C., media market, earning 20 Emmy and Edward R. Murrow awards along the way [4]. Before joining CBS News as a congressional correspondent in late 2021, he spent eight years at WRC-TV, the NBC affiliate in Washington, where his investigative reporting led directly to the passage of five new state laws in Virginia, Maryland, and Washington, D.C., bolstering protections for children in public schools [4]. His investigations into the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs prompted a congressional review, and his reporting on thoroughbred horse racing deaths in West Virginia resulted in new state safety regulations [5].

But it was his coverage of January 6 that defined his CBS tenure. From the moment a mob scaled the walls of the U.S. Capitol in 2021, MacFarlane threw himself into what became an all-consuming assignment — often working 10-hour days chronicling the largest criminal prosecution in American history [6]. He tracked more than 1,600 federal cases stemming from the Capitol siege, a body of work that earned him recognition from the Journalism Salute project and cemented his reputation as one of the most dogged justice reporters in Washington [6].

His final article for CBS, published March 6, 2026 — just three days before his departure announcement — addressed the very same subject that had shaped his years at the network: the aftermath of January 6 [1].

What Drove Him Out

MacFarlane framed his departure diplomatically, but reporting from The Guardian's Jeremy Barr revealed that he was known to be "unhappy with the network's very brief mention of the Jan. 6 anniversary on the CBS Evening News" [1]. In the context of the broader upheaval at CBS News, his frustration with diminished coverage of the Capitol riot's legal fallout reads as a proxy for deeper concerns about the network's editorial trajectory.

Those concerns are widely shared. In the months since David Ellison's Skydance Media completed its takeover of Paramount Global — the parent company of CBS — in mid-2025, the network has undergone what critics describe as a rightward editorial recalibration driven by political and commercial considerations [7]. Ellison, whose family maintains ties to the Trump orbit, tapped Bari Weiss — the conservative writer, Free Press founder, and vocal critic of legacy media — to serve as CBS News editor-in-chief in October 2025 [8]. Paramount simultaneously acquired Weiss's publication, The Free Press, for $150 million [9].

The Bari Weiss Era

Weiss wasted little time reshaping CBS News in her image. In a January 2026 all-hands meeting, she told staff that without a shift in strategy, "we are toast," and announced a slate of new network contributors drawn heavily from The Free Press's roster, including Harvard professor Arthur Brooks, historian Niall Ferguson, writer Coleman Hughes, and technology journalist Patrick McGee [10]. She also told employees they were free to leave if dissatisfied with her leadership: "It's a free country, and I completely respect if you decide I'm not the right leader for you" [11].

Many took her up on the offer.

In December 2025, Weiss pulled a 60 Minutes segment titled "Inside CECOT," an investigation into El Salvador's Terrorism Confinement Center, on the grounds that it needed an on-camera interview with someone from the Trump administration [8]. The decision sent shockwaves through the newsroom. By early 2026, top producers of 60 Minutes — CBS's flagship newsmagazine — had quit, airing complaints of interference in their editorial independence [7].

Source: GDELT Project

Data as of Mar 10, 2026CSV

A Cascade of Departures

MacFarlane is far from alone. The list of high-profile exits from CBS News since the Ellison-Weiss era began reads like a roll call of the network's recent identity:

• John Dickerson, co-anchor of the CBS Evening News, announced in October 2025 that he would leave the network after 16 years [12].
• Maurice DuBois, Dickerson's co-anchor, departed in December 2025, with his last broadcast on December 18 [12].
• Anderson Cooper resigned from his 60 Minutes correspondent role in February 2026, citing discomfort with the network's "rightward direction" [1].
• Mary Walsh, a CBS News producer with 46 years at the network, resigned in February 2026 [13].
• Alicia Hastey, a CBS Evening News producer, resigned with a critical farewell note warning that stories were being evaluated based on "ideological expectations" rather than journalistic merit [11].
• Claudia Milne, head of CBS News standards, departed the network [14].

Beyond voluntary departures, the October 2025 layoffs swept through the organization, affecting close to 100 staffers [14]. CBS Saturday Morning hosts Michelle Miller and Dana Jacobson, correspondents Nikki Battiste and Janet Shamlian — both Peabody and Emmy winners — and senior foreign correspondent Debora Patta were all let go [14]. Lisa Ling, who had joined from The View, was also terminated [15]. The network closed its Johannesburg bureau and eliminated its Race & Culture Unit, which had been established in 2020 following the killing of George Floyd [14].

Approximately 25% of eligible CBS Evening News staff took voluntary buyouts, with 11 staffers accepting packages, including at least six producers out of roughly 20 on staff [11]. A new round of layoffs in 2026 is expected to affect at least 15% of the CBS News workforce [16].

The Political Backdrop

The transformation at CBS did not occur in a vacuum. Before the Skydance deal was finalized, Paramount agreed to pay $16 million in response to President Trump's complaint over CBS's coverage of the 2024 election [7]. FCC Chairman Brendan Carr said the deal included an "unprecedented promise" that the organization would "root out bias that has undermined trust" [7].

Victor Pickard, professor of media policy and political economy at the University of Pennsylvania, told NPR that the new approach under Ellison is "primarily to appease or curry favor with the Trump administration in anticipation for an aspiring acquisition of Warner Brothers Discovery" [17]. The network also selected a new CBS News ombudsman with "strong conservative credentials" and promised to run full, unedited interviews on its public affairs shows after receiving criticism from Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem [7].

The editorial changes under Weiss have been characterized by some departing staff as driven by a "clearly defined political agenda" [3]. One CBS staffer, speaking anonymously, described the coverage environment bluntly as "Propaganda-palooza" [3].

Source: GDELT Project

Data as of Mar 10, 2026CSV

A Broader Industry Reckoning

MacFarlane's departure arrives at a moment of existential crisis for American journalism. According to the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, only 38% of media executives feel confident about journalism's future — a 22-percentage-point drop from just four years ago [18]. Meanwhile, only 28% of Americans report having a "great deal or fair amount of trust" in mass media [19].

The "twin squeeze" of AI-powered answer engines and personality-driven creators represents an unprecedented dual threat to traditional news organizations, with AI platforms potentially cutting publisher traffic by 43% [18]. Populist politicians on both sides of the Atlantic have adopted playbooks for ignoring, denigrating, or undermining institutional journalism [18].

CBS is not the only legacy outlet navigating these pressures. But the speed and scale of its transformation — and the number of experienced journalists who have chosen to leave rather than work under the new regime — make it a particularly vivid case study.

What Comes Next

For MacFarlane, the path forward remains undefined. His LinkedIn announcement suggested he would seek independent platforms for his work, though he did not specify where or in what format. Given his deep expertise in federal criminal cases and congressional proceedings — and his unusual combination of investigative chops and on-camera presence — he is unlikely to remain silent for long.

For CBS News, the question is whether the departures will slow or accelerate. With another round of layoffs looming, Bari Weiss's vision of a network that appeals to "political moderates" [10] will face a practical test: whether there are enough journalists willing to execute it, and whether viewers will follow.

Tony Dokoupil, who took over as CBS Evening News anchor on January 5, 2026 — the sixth person to hold that title in a decade — represents the new face of the network [12]. His first week drew lower ratings than his predecessors [12]. The no. 2 producer on his broadcast was subsequently fired [20].

The departure of Scott MacFarlane, a reporter who spent four years tenaciously chronicling the legal aftermath of an assault on American democracy, may ultimately say more about the state of American media than about any one correspondent's career choices. When a journalist known for covering accountability decides he can no longer do that work at his own network, the implications extend far beyond the walls of any single newsroom.