Reform UK Spokesman Faces Backlash Over Resurfaced Mosque Video

On a spring evening in April 2019, Simon Dudley — then leader of the Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead — stood before congregants at Maidenhead Mosque and made a promise. Vote Conservative, he told them, and the council would hand the mosque neighbouring land it needed to expand. It was, an independent investigation later concluded, a promise built on falsehoods designed to sway an election [1][2].

Seven years later, Dudley has resurfaced in British politics — this time as Reform UK's housing and infrastructure spokesman, appointed by deputy leader Richard Tice [3]. The appointment has reignited scrutiny of his record at a moment when Reform UK's relationship with Britain's Muslim communities is under intense examination, the party leads national polls, and anti-Muslim hate crimes have hit record levels across England and Wales [4][5].

The Maidenhead Mosque Speech

The controversy centres on a speech Dudley delivered at Maidenhead Mosque on April 26, 2019, during the legally sensitive pre-election "purdah" period when council officials are expected to exercise political neutrality [1][2].

Dudley told mosque members that the council was negotiating with the neighbouring Ivy Leaf Club to surrender its lease, and that the land would be transferred to the Islamic Trust for the mosque's expansion. He concluded with an explicit appeal: "I hope when we have our local government elections… you will vote Conservative" [2].

The problem: the claim was factually false. Negotiations with the Ivy Leaf Club had ceased in September 2018 due to a lack of suitable relocation sites. The club's lease still had 27 years remaining, and its secretary publicly accused Dudley of "blatant electioneering," promising something "that was not available" [6].

An investigation by solicitor Richard Lingard, commissioned by the council, concluded that Dudley's speech likely "'swayed' some of the voters to vote blue — 'clearly his intention'" [2][7]. The investigator also found that a confidential draft agreement had been prepared by the council's acting chief executive, Russell O'Keefe, just two days before Dudley's address — though Lingard cleared O'Keefe of direct conspiracy [7].

Critically, Dudley resigned as both council leader and councillor before the investigation could formally interview him, limiting its scope [2]. The report's most damning conclusions were then redacted, triggering a three-year freedom of information battle that saw key findings finally made public only in 2022 through a first-tier tribunal order [1][7].

A Pattern of Controversy

The mosque speech was not Dudley's first brush with public backlash. In January 2018, he attracted national and international condemnation for writing to Thames Valley Police demanding a crackdown on rough sleepers ahead of the royal wedding of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle [8].

Dudley described homeless people's belongings as "bags and detritus" and suggested some rough sleepers had made a "commercial life choice praying on residents and tourists." The remarks prompted a petition attracting over 270,000 signatures, the resignation of three Conservative councillors from his group in protest, and a vote of no confidence — which he survived 43-9 [8].

He later apologised, saying he had not been referring to "genuine homeless people."

From Homes England to Reform UK

After leaving local government, Dudley pivoted to the housing quango world. He held positions at Homes England between 2017 and 2021, including a stint of just over a year as interim chair of the board. He subsequently chaired the Ebbsfleet Development Corporation from 2021 to 2025 [3][9].

His appointment as Reform UK's housing spokesman, announced in early 2026, was framed around his professional credentials. "Britain faces a building crisis. Young people are locked out of home ownership," Dudley said in a statement, pledging to lead a review of planning costs, delays, and housing delivery [3]. Robert Jenrick, the former Conservative immigration minister who defected to Reform, endorsed the appointment on social media, calling Dudley someone with "real world experience to break the cycle of broken promises" [10] — an ironic choice of phrase given the Maidenhead Mosque investigation's findings.

Reform UK's Broader Tensions with Muslim Communities

Dudley's appointment lands in a deeply fraught context. Reform UK has spent early 2026 pursuing an aggressive cultural agenda around religion and identity that has alarmed Muslim leaders and civil liberties groups.

In February, home affairs spokesperson Zia Yusuf — himself a practising Muslim and former Reform UK chairman — announced the party would "grant listed status automatically to all churches and prohibit" their conversion into mosques, framing it as protecting Britain's "Christian heritage" [11][12].

The policy's factual basis has been extensively challenged. Since 1968, only two Church of England churches have been sold and converted into other places of worship — both becoming Sikh gurdwaras, not mosques. Church law expert Nigel Walter told reporters the proposal addresses a "largely fictional problem," noting that consecrated Anglican buildings are already subject to restrictive covenants making conversion "almost impossible" [13].

Source: UK Home Office / Hate Crime Statistics

Data as of Oct 9, 2025CSV

Yusuf cited a figure of 41 churches converted to mosques, drawn from a user-edited Wikipedia list [13]. The Big Issue's investigation found that Reform's figures conflate purpose-built 1960s-era non-conformist chapels — "buildings that look like village halls" — with the medieval parish churches the policy evokes in the public imagination [13].

Asim Qari, imam at Leeds Makkah Masjid and chair of the Mosques and Imams National Advisory Board, accused Reform of attempting to "pit faith communities against each other," warning that "attempts to frame lawful religious practice as a threat risk undermining the unity that has made Britain strong" [11].

The Wider Climate

The political backdrop is stark. Anti-Muslim hate crimes in England and Wales reached 3,199 recorded offences in the year ending March 2025 — a 19% increase on the previous year, driven in part by a spike following the Southport murders in July 2024 and subsequent far-right disorder [4]. School suspensions for racist behaviour have more than doubled in recent years, with children as young as four being sent home [5]. Mosques have been vandalised — Basildon Mosque was daubed with red crosses and "This is England" graffiti — and Muslim families have reported drivers accelerating as women with children cross roads [5].

Reform UK now polls at approximately 28% nationally, holding a seven-point lead over Labour according to Ipsos fieldwork from March 2026. A January MRP projection by More in Common suggested the party would win a parliamentary majority if an election were held [14][15].

The party's internal record on anti-Muslim incidents continues to accumulate. In January 2026, a Reform UK councillor in Coventry was condemned as "openly Islamophobic" after linking Muslim prayer times to crime rates [16]. In Doncaster, councillor Paul Cutts was suspended pending investigation after Facebook posts targeting the Muslim faith, including a video of people in Islamic dress in a UK supermarket captioned "England shouldn't look like this" [17]. Cutts later visited a local mosque and described the experience as "extremely enlightening."

What the Appointment Signals

Dudley's appointment raises uncomfortable questions that Reform UK has yet to publicly address. The party did not respond to questions about whether it was aware of the Maidenhead Mosque investigation when it hired him, or whether his record was vetted.

The broader pattern — a housing spokesman who once made false promises to a mosque to win Conservative votes, now serving a party that campaigns to prevent churches from becoming mosques — speaks to a tension at the heart of Reform UK's populist project. The party seeks to present itself as a serious governing alternative with heavyweight policy credentials, while simultaneously pursuing culture-war positioning that experts and religious leaders say is built on misleading statistics and risks inflaming community tensions.

For Maidenhead Mosque, the promises Dudley made in 2019 never materialised. The Ivy Leaf Club site the mosque was told it could acquire was later earmarked for housing development, leaving the mosque "shocked" that its community space needs had been disregarded [6]. The congregation that Dudley addressed seven years ago is still waiting to expand.

Whether Reform UK's housing spokesman has learned anything from that broken pledge — or whether broken pledges are simply the cost of doing politics — remains an open question as the party positions itself for power.